top of page

Steady Improvement

hydesollie
30 minutes ago
4 min read

Toulouse, October 2026.


My wife and I emerge from the train station to a gorgeous morning. High above, the sun, accompanied by the gentlest of breezes, shines brightly.


Amidst the hustle and bustle, we make our way to a nearby hotel. Then into the heart of the city.


Immediately, a raft of memories, from my previous visit to the “Pink City” some three decades earlier, come flooding back.


We amble along the Allee Jean Jaures, a starting point for an array of vibrant squares, busy arcades, sidewalk cafes, enticing gourmet shops. Any number of talented street artists and musicians just add to the magic.


Continuing on, we marvel at the magnificent Basilica of Saint-Sernin, a UNESCO World Heritage site, at the palm tree columns at the Convent of the Jacobins, as well as the Capitolium.


The time flies by. Shiny, cobbled streets lead us to the banks of the Garonne River. Many of the scenic views include the iconic Pont-Neuf, a 17th century bridge still viewed as a masterpiece of the Renaissance Age.


However, for me at least, one other landmark, much newer, strikes a particularly deep chord. For, a mere kilometre north west of the city centre, in the district of Sept-Deniers, sits Stade Ernest-Wallon. Built in 1983, named after the club’s founder and now with a seating capacity of 20,000, it is home to Stade Toulousain. By anyone’s criteria, one the most distinguished and successful rugby union clubs in the world.


Not surprisingly, the sport being something of a religion in the south of France, the venue also hosts numerous other major international rugby events.


One concludes in the spring of 1998.


It is Saturday, April 12.


A healthy crowd fills the stadium. The sixteen team FIRA U19 World Championship draws to a close. The tournament final, to the absolute delight of the rugby mad locals, pits France vs Ireland. The hosts, hot favourites, field a roster packed with talented youngsters on the cusp of stardom. The upstart Irish less heralded yet buoyed by earlier victories vs USA, South Africa, and Argentina.


The respective anthems complete, the game begins. The pressure is palpable. The action fast and furious, the French perhaps caught off guard by the ferocity and determination of their opponents. Indeed, Ireland quickly opens the scoring, notching a converted try in the 8th minute to lead 7-0.


Stung into action, France fights back. A flowing backline move, complete with slick passes and decoy runners, sees the team sweep over halfway. The fullback finds a half gap, releases the ball towards a winger flying up the sideline. An equalizing score looks a distinct possibility. Defenders in proximity, but this time scrambling desperately, out of position. The referee in line, but his view partially blocked by bodies.


Then comes a pivotal moment. The French winger suddenly breaks stride. The pass intended for him, goes loose. Skips past, then slithers into touch. Throw in, Ireland ball.


To say the highly partisan crowd is not happy with this development would be an understatement. Shouting, jeering, whistling. gesticulating wildly, they berate the referee for failing to notice an obvious obstruction.


Several of the French players are equally furious. The captain’s petulance, “stink eye” glare, and palms up gesture, speak volumes.


I certainly sense the hostility. And I should know.


Because the referee in question is me.



I need to collect myself. And quickly. Need to focus. Need to stay calm. Must not allow a perceived error to derail the rest of the match.


In this regard, the Irish come to my rescue. In a suffocating and disciplined defensive display, they absolutely smother any other French attacks. Refuse to rise to any provocation. Despite battling a strong wind after halftime, they dominate collisions, control territory, and play to their considerable strengths. Add a second try. An earlier penalty goal and a drop goal further secure a significant, decisive 18-0 win.


The comprehensive victory, and the manner in which it is achieved, eventually draws a grudging ovation from the French public in attendance. Likewise, rave reviews from both the Irish and French media. Luckily for me, there are no further mentions of the referee. Not even a passing reference to likely interference on the French wing with the game still in the balance.


It is only later I come to realize that the 1998 tournament success reflects a turning point in Irish rugby culture.


Several of that U19 World championship team, starting with the legendary Brian O’Driscoll, eventually join the full Senior Men’s squad. Quickly, the national XV, with winning now an expectation, emerge and remain a legitimate force on the world scene.


However, back to refereeing.


It remains a most challenging job. Top fitness levels? Non-negotiable. A sense of humour and strong communication skills? Invaluable. Getting the big decisions correct, especially concerning tries and foul play, without endless television match official interventions? Critical.


Meanwhile, rugby’s labyrinthine laws need careful navigation. Endless tinkering with the scrum now requires management of early engagement, properly tucked shoulders, the brake foot, and walking around. Add in trying to keep players on their feet and coming through “the gate” at rucks and mauls. With hip and knee drop tackles, dangerous cleanouts, head contact, possible mitigation, all part of ongoing safety initiatives. Never mind having to deal with squawks and squeals from irritated coaches, players and spectators. Or the ever increasing chatter by keyboard warriors on social media platforms.


As a result, unfortunately, even seventy or eighty minutes of accuracy and clarity can be undone by the tiniest of errors.


A nearby clock chimes. It is 6pm. I snap out of my reverie. It is time to go.


The Stade Ernest-Wallon sits empty, though ready for its next match. I hope to return again one day. To the site of one of my most treasured sporting memories.



Still, I chuckle to myself. Know that whatever the sport, from peewee level to professional, the referee will be always under the microscope. And that, in the eyes of many, the expectation will be perfection at the start.


And then steady improvement.

 

 


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


A Life In Sport.-4.png

Never Miss A Blog Post:

This site created by:

Zac Andrus Creative Paypal Logo.png

©2020 by Ian Hyde-Lay

bottom of page